Electric Propulsion Systems for Manned Aircraft

    Current electric propulsion technology intended for manned atmospheric flight involves replacing the internal combustion piston-propeller engine or the turboprop engine (turbine-compressor + shaft output to propeller or rotor) with electric motors to drive the propellers or rotors. Propellers are more efficient than jet engines for subsonic propulsion [NASA source and another external source]. At such low velocities, electric motors are much more efficient than internal combustion engines or jet engines and have better torque-to-weight ratios as well. (See the linked Wikipedia article with the comparison of electric motors to IC engines.) 

    Consequently, there is a move afoot to design and build all electric propeller driven aircraft, primarily in the small aircraft category,  by such big name players as NASA (check out the Puffin one-man concept aircraft), Cessna, Sikorsky and EADS.

    One could ask, why not Electric Jet Propulsion?  Electric space propulsion systems have been around for a few years, used mainly for satellite attitude control, in the form of plasma jets, such as Hall effect thrusters, ion thrusters, VASIMR jet, etc. But the thrust levels of electric plasma jet engines are very tiny, in the range of a few milliNewtons, although their specific impulses are in the range of 5000, compared to about 500 for chemical rockets. In the low-gravity, zero air friction environment of outer space, spacecraft can use electric jets to gradually build up to extremely high velocities, in the hundreds of 1000s of km/hr. This idea was proposed to be used for the mission to Mars and was first tested on the Deep Space 1 mission. Electric jet propulsion systems are therefore currently relegated to low-gravity space applications only.

    Many may be familiar with the older, widely adopted concept called More Electric Aircraft (MEA) which was intended to replace mechanical actuators and control devices with electromechanical actuators. Instead of having a large hydraulic pump located centrally with miles of high pressure plumbing laid out all over the aircraft, smaller electromechanical actuators, which have a small pump and hydraulic actuator all built into one unit, could be mounted directly at the point where actuation is required, such as in the wing flaps for example. This move not only brings about safety from totally removing pipe bursts or leaks, but also reduces weight, power consumption and response times. Many military and civilian aircraft manufacturers have adopted the MEA approach, especially with the wide-spread use of the fly-by-wire technology. The MEA method is a big step towards bringing the all-electric vehicle into a reality. Moog is a well known supplier of aircraft components that follow the MEA concept.

    Back to current electric airplanes.

    Here is a link to an article on Boeing’s single prop airplane, powered jointly by a hydrogen fuel cell and lithium-ion battery pack, which cruised for 20 minutes at a top speed of 62 mph during a test flight in Spain in early 2009. The Dimona has a 53.5 ft wingspan and uses a single PEM fuel cell along with the Li-ion batteries for storage.

    Cessna (a division of Textron, which also owns Bell Helicopter, Lycoming Engines, E-Z-GO_golf  carts, trams, etc._ and other companies) has teamed up with Bye Energy to develop an electric version of the Cessna 172 single-engine airplane. (Here is a link to an article on that project.) Bye Energy is  headquartered in Englewood, Colorado, with offices at the Arizona State University SkySong Innovation Center in Scottsdale, Arizona and Albuquerque, New Mexico. The first flight of the electric airplane is expected to take place by the end of 2010. (Here is a press release from Bye Energy.) Bye Energy is involved in developing biofuels for aviation (alternatives for 100LL fuel for IC engines and Jet A for turbine engines) as well as a collaborative effort to create electric hybrid propulsion systems for aircraft, called the Green Flight Project.

    Sikorsky Aircraft company (a division of United Technologies Corp. which also owns Pratt & Whitney a/c engines, Hamilton Sunstrand aero sytems, Carrier air conditioning, Otis elevators, etc.) plans to fly an electric motor powered light helicopter (the S-300C 3-bladed main rotor, used for training and agricultural purposes) by the end of 2010 under project Firefly. They will replace the 190 hp avgas powered Lycoming engine with a 190hp electric motor and Li-ion battery pack, giving it a estimated flight time of 15 minutes. (Here is a press release from Sikorsky.)

    The European Aeronautic Defence and Space Company (EADS) has the Cri-Cri (Really? What a creative name indeed!), a four-propeller & motor light aircraft with high density Lithium polymer battery packs (22 kW total power). The Cri-Cri made its debut flight in August 2010 in the French city of Royan. The motors powered by the battery pack give the airplane the ability to takeoff, climb, cruise and land for a total autonomous flight time of about 20 to 30 minutes. The Cri-Cri has a wingspan of 4.9 m (16 ft) and a fuselage length of 3.9 m (12.8 ft). This article has some photos and a 3 minute video clip.

    Sonex Aircraft company, based in Oshkosh, Wisconsin, launched their E-Flight Initiative in 2006 to explore alternative energy systems to power sport aircraft. Their main focus is in the sport class of aircraft. Sonex is working on developing an electric motor propeller system as well as ethanol based IC engines. Sonex sells kits for various light sport airplanes. (Here is a press release from Sonex.)

    I think that the best approach for an electric aircraft would be to go hybrid. Battery technology is the  limiting factor that is holding up long duration endurance flights. Fuel cells still have a long way to go before they are reliable and cost effective. Therefore, although electric propulsion is very viable in terms of improved efficiency, lower weight and lower costs, an onboard electric power generator will be required. The most compact fuel sources are chemical fuels. Just as in the case of the Jaguar C-X75, the best option for onboard electric power is to use a constant speed turbine engine rotating an electric generator. The turbine engine provides the versatility to use a variety of fuels, gaseous and liquids, both biofuels as well as conventional fuels. The turbine is a reliable prime mover that is compact and light weight. Large battery packs, which are not at all environmentally friendly, can be eliminated. Having a liquid fuel tank with a fuel gauge gives one the ability to confidently predict range and trajectory.

    Here is an article from Popular Mechanics explaining why current Federal Aviation Administration rules for light sport aircraft (LSA) are holding back the progress in electric propulsion for that class of aircraft.

    This article from Aviation Week has some updates on new projects in the Electric Airplane frontier.

Advertisements

About propulsiontech

Propulsion technologist, aerospace engineer
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Electric Propulsion Systems for Manned Aircraft

  1. Pingback: Carspike.com

  2. lithium semi-open nano cell poly’ foam has 1,000 times the suface area of a normal lithium polymer battery’s and if used with a neodymium magnetic armature motor that has electonic controlled coils using back to back FETS then a plane could fly all round the world without re-energizing!
    note for scientists :- electric planes flying in the stratosphere can collect ozone this gas is magnetic and can be made to discharge, when this happens it can pass surplus electrical energy to enable lithium batteries to be charged whilst flying!
    Note ozone discharges electrical energy to cloud vapour droplets continously 24 hours day and night! the left over oxygen from the ozone discharge process, can then be used for breathing within the plane! most scientists no that ozone can be disassociated in several ways! in this case discharging within a tube magnet containing fin rolled nickel gause which is connectd to the negetive of the plane motors or generator!

  3. lithium semi-open nano cell poly’ foam has 1,000 times the suface area of a normal lithium polymer battery’s and if used in conjunction with a new type neodymium magnetic armature motor that has electonic controlled coils using back to back FETS then a plane could fly all round the world without re-energizing!
    note for scientists :- electric planes flying in the stratosphere can collect ozone this gas is magnetic and can be made to discharge, when this happens it can pass surplus electrical energy to enable lithium batteries to be charged whilst flying!
    Note ozone discharges electrical energy to cloud vapour droplets continously 24 hours day and night! on board the plane the resultent left over oxygen from the ozone discharge process, can then be used for breathing within the plane! most scientists know that ozone can be disassociated in several ways! in this case discharging within a tube magnet containing fine rolled nickel gause which is connected to a voltage regulator and the resultant current can charge the new lithium nano foam polymer batteries!

  4. electric charge can shield gravity’ and can be projected electricallt from within a craft module. ro peripheral circumference! Fact! in ofder to bring about buoyancy within the atomophere! Fact!

    direct photon vectors can act as gravity
    electrically charge air will levitate molecules if used cleverly;
    volume and density of air is equal to the sum of applied m · g = q · E

    Millikan rays ionizing the air, so that differing numbers of bulk photons would jump onto the oil molecules each time. He obtained various values for q.

    q representing electrical charge;

    The charge q on a drop was always a multiple of 1.60 x 10-19 Coulombs

  5. electric charge can shield gravity’ and can be projected electrically from within a craft module to the peripheral circumference! Fact! objective is to bring about aircraft buoyancy within the atomophere! Fact!
    Note; direct photon vectors can act as gravity
    electrically charged air will levitate molecules if used cleverly;
    modus is to increase air density underneath aircraft ib order to save fuel etc!
    volume and density of air is equal to the sum of applied m · g = q · E

    Millikan rays ionizing the air, so that differing numbers of bulk photons would jump onto the oil molecules each time. He obtained various values for q.

    q representing electrical charge;

    The charge q on a drop was always a multiple of 1.60 x 10-19 Coulombs’ same applies to air!

  6. Andrew, Thanks. What do you mean by FETS, field effect transistors? Li batteries have a promising future, although other high density batteries are being developed.
    Your ozone idea sounds novel to me. Is there enough ozone density in the stratosphere to provide enough current for the propulsion system? I’d like to study your suggestions using ozone further.
    I have come across gravity shielding before via the LANL archive. Just search for gravity shielding at the archive site. Gravity shielding would be possible if the electrodynamic theory of gravity is true, which I believe it is. (I also favor plasma cosmology and think that quantum mechanics and relativity have been falsified thoroughly.)
    However, ionization of air alone will not provide enough thrust to lift a heavy aircraft. Are you familiar with Jean-Louis Naudin and his lifter? You can watch videos of the ionic lifter on his website, and many others have followed his directions to build their own ionic lifters, made out of balsa wood and Al foil. The ionic wind produced by the ionic lifters is rather low in force and velocity.

  7. I’ve been exploring for a bit for any high-quality articles or weblog posts on this kind of house . Exploring in Yahoo I finally stumbled upon this site. Studying this information So i’m glad to show that I’ve an incredibly excellent uncanny feeling I came upon exactly what I needed. I such a lot unquestionably will make sure to don?t overlook this web site and give it a glance on a continuing basis.

  8. note; if high magnetic fields are created such as 100T then atoms can be homolgized together in a super cell formation’ thus heavy objects like aircraft and other heavy objects can be buoyed up by the homologized atoms that are bunched tightly together by the magnetic field example; 100T-200T

    TeSLA new this but no one took any notice! Gravity can be managed in this way and is the future of Physics’ note; simple thrusting current thrugh a copper coil is cromagnonship’ magnetic power fields are best created by vector electric field same as stars’ the magnetic field is always 90 degrees to the electric field in the absence of high temperature’ the way to build an electric charge of high value is to use a huge high voltage vander-graff capacitor ship/ball or similar’ this will project an electric vector at 90 degrees as the current is increased the magnetic field builds at 90 degrees the projected electric field’ and the atoms compact closer and closer together until a super cell is developed’ at high magnetic value atoms dipoles line up and increase the overall magnetic effect’ that can become self sustaining’ Note this is not iron magnetism but atom magnetism and the formed super cell density is more than sufficient to lift 100s of tonnes and provide a thrust vector as well’ initial power is created by using magnetic flux compression using a super compressed air’ this is air that is frozen and then released at enormous pressures’ which uses air hydraulics to increase pressure still further! the air is used over and over again! note; the full electric current does not need to active continuosly’ as atoms when homologized together super magnetically will tend to remain at the arrived density’ you can prove this in the lab’ as TeSLA did with his super DC coils they will rise from a table top without a metal plate underneath to provide opposing polarity lift energy! the tesla coils will sustain lift at extreme current values or if the coils are chilled with nitrogen’ this old method was totally un-economic and Tesla did not fully understand about the atoms homologizing tightly together’ his coils did not present the magnetic field over sufficient volume in order to gain an economic lift ratio’that at high values will self sustain!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s